What Nicole Wore

style + beauty blog in the dc metro area

  • Home
  • About
    • Disclosure & Privacy
  • Contact
  • Instagram
    • Shop My Instagram
  • Outfits
    • How to Wear Items & Closet Remix Tips
    • Fall Outfits
    • Winter Outfits
    • Derby
    • Spring Outfits
    • Summer Outfits
    • All Outfits
You are here: Home / Beauty / Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

March 23, 2016

It’s not exactly a big secret that I’m not a fan of drugstore foundations; it’s not from a snobby, “I’m better than that” standpoint because if I could, please know that I would, but comes from the fact that Target/Walgreen’s/CVS/Wal-Mart don’t usually have makeup artists walking around, ready to help you find your perfect match.

And sure enough, when Influenster sent me my first bottle of the Maybelline Fit Me! Foundation, it was a bust. While the shade is much too dark, I have liked using it around the outside of my face as a bronzer.  Influenster was kind enough to send me a second bottle of the foundation and I wanted to share my thoughts on it as well as some of the beauty products I’ve been using lately.

Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation
featured in this post: gorgeous moisturizer + colourpop ultra satin lipstick + stila liquid eyeliner + blending sponge + nars blush + tarte lip crayon in thirsty + maybelline fit me foundation in toffee c/o influenster + maybelline fit me foundation in coconut c/o influenster + tarte waterproof brow pencil + nyx matte finish setting spray + becca shimmering skin perfecter in opal + colourpop ultra satin lipstick + tarte clay blush in tipsy + urban decay naked palette
I used one of my unused blending sponges for this picture because they look gross once they’ve been used — just keeping it real.  I like to dampen my blender before using a “dotting” motion to smooth out my foundation and make it look more natural.
Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

While this shade was a closer match to my skin tone, I found that the color was a little too orange and streaky in some places and just a touch too dark.  It’s most obvious in the picture I grabbed from Snapchat further down in this post, but the foundation does not match my neck at all — and that’s after I blended a bit into my neck.Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

I’ve used this foundation for a few days so I could compare it to the Tarte 12 Hour that I usually wear.  While the Maybelline claims to be a matte and poreless, I found myself getting shiny a few hours after application.  The formula is very runny while Tarte feels more like a gel or thick primer.  I stayed away from liquid foundations for awhile because runny tends to mean messy in my experience. Sure enough, as I was getting ready to take these photos, I found foundation leaking out under the cap of one of the bottles.

I will say that for $8 {and knowing that Ulta frequently runs BOGO 50 promos on Maybelline products}, this foundation is pretty good. Unfortunately, I’m pretty particular about finding a foundation that fits me a little more than this one did and I’ve learned to be used to paying a little more to have that peace of mind.  {Ultra, Sephora and Bare Minerals are all examples of beauty stores that will help you find a match for a non drugstore product, no purchase necessary!}

Still, if I were ever in a jam, forgot my makeup and needed something quick and cheap to get the job done, I’d be willing to pick up this foundation over previous drugstore brands I’ve had.
Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

I started to get low on my Gimme Brow a few weeks ago, so I decided to give Tarte’s brow pencil a try while Ulta was rewarding 5x points on their products. I love that the pencil twists up {like their lip pencils} and is very buildable. I typically “outline” my brow before going back in with lighter, feathery strokes to fill in any areas where my eyebrow may be a bit sparse.  This also has a spooly brush on the opposite end so you can brush your eyebrows into place prior to penciling and soften up any strokes that look too harsh afterwards.  Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

Loving this color so hard! I ordered three of the ultra satin lips when they first came out and didn’t get this color after seeing some beauty bloggers saying that it was too bright.  I’ve been looking for a bright pink lipstick so when I placed my last order, I ended up putting this one in my online cart. It’s a hot pink with blue undertones and in the tube, I wondered if I was going to look clown-ish.  While it’s definitely a bold color, I think it’s perfect for spring.
Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

{Please tell me I’m not the only person that has an iPhone photo album full of unpublished Snapchat selfies of different lipstick shades for personal reference….}

You can see here the very obvious difference in color between my face and neck. I don’t mind blending a little foundation into my neck, but full out applying it is something I don’t want or need to do.Review: Maybelline Fit Me Foundation

Thank you to Influenster for allowing me to try out the Maybelline Fit Me Matte Foundation! I was provided two bottles of the foundation by Influenster for testing and reviewing purposes.

SHOP THE POST

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Email
  • More
  • Tumblr
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon

Related


Filed Under: BeautyTagged: influenster, maybelline

I'm Nicole, a life and style enthusiast living in northern Virginia. Stick with me and I'll share the best deals and easy ways to live your best life, in style of course. Thanks so much for stopping by!

Disclosure

Thank you for supporting What Nicole Wore! What Nicole Wore is apart of several affiliate programs that allow a commission for purchases made through this site {with no extra cost to you}. All gifted products are noted with c/o & sponsored posts are specifically called out.  All opinions shared are solely mine.

SHOP MY POSTS

let’s get social!

  • Bloglovin
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Follow Me on Pinterest!

Follow me on Bloglovin

Follow

Theme Design By Studio Mommy · Copyright © 2025

Copyright © 2025 · Ashley Scott Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

We use cookies to give you the best experience on What Nicole Wore.

You can find out more about which cookies we use or switch them off in .

What Nicole Wore
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.